Turkey Noodle Soup With a Creamy Broth and Noodles That Stay Tender

Turkey noodle soup with carrots, peas and hominy

A pot of turkey noodle soup can look just right at dinner and surprisingly thick the next day. The noodles keep taking up liquid as they sit. Cooking them separately gives you more control, especially when the soup is meant to stretch beyond one meal.

Creamy turkey soup with vegetables, hominy and separately cooked egg noodles.
Turkey noodle soup with tender meat and broad noodles

This turkey noodle soup combines cooked turkey, vegetables, hominy and a lightly thickened cream broth. Add separately cooked egg noodles to each bowl so the pot keeps its broth and the noodles keep their shape.

The creamy direction comes from Chef Billy Parisi’s turkey soup, with measured vegetable and turkey weights. I like the separate-noodle approach because it solves a real leftover problem without asking anyone to make a second soup.

Ingredients for turkey noodle soup with cooked turkey, egg noodles and vegetables

Serving Turkey Noodle Soup

Spoon a portion of noodles into a warm bowl, then ladle the soup over them. This lets you adjust the balance for someone who wants more broth or fewer noodles. It also keeps the main pot easier to portion if everyone is eating at a slightly different time.

The soup contains turkey, noodles, vegetables and cream, so bread is optional rather than a necessary completion. If you offer it, keep the slices small and let people decide. A crisp salad can provide a different texture without competing with the bowl.

  • For a lighter bowl: start with fewer noodles, then add more if wanted.
  • For family service: keep noodles and soup in separate serving vessels.
  • For a fresh side: a simple cucumber salad gives a cool contrast to the creamy broth.
PlanKeep separateBenefit
Serving immediatelyNoodles until bowls are readyEasier portion control
Saving leftoversSoup and noodlesLess absorbed broth
Reheating a portionOnly what you will eatMore predictable texture
Separate noodles make both dinner and leftovers easier to manage.

Let the noodles meet the broth in the bowl, especially when you expect leftovers.

Turkey Noodle Soup Variations

This is a creamy soup rather than a clear turkey broth. The small stock-vermouth reduction and the flour thickener are part of that character, so removing both changes the dish substantially. You can make a simpler variation, but it should not be described as the same finished soup.

I would adjust the thickness with a little stock or water before adding more cream. The noodles and flour already contribute body, and a soup that looks loose in the pot can feel fuller once it reaches the bowl. Add liquid gradually so the flavor does not become diluted.

  • Different cooked poultry: plain cooked chicken can replace turkey, with a different estimate.
  • No vermouth: use stock for an alcohol-free variation and expect less aromatic sharpness.
  • Different noodles: cook the chosen shape separately according to its package.
  • No hominy: another vegetable creates a different texture; hominy is not the same as sweetcorn.
  • More vegetables: use similar-size pieces and check tenderness before adding the cream finish.

Keep the separate-noodle habit even when you change the vegetables or use another cooked poultry.

Creamy turkey noodle soup base with cooked noodles kept separately

Nutrition and Safe Cooking

Turkey contributes protein, and the vegetables, peas and noodles make the soup more substantial than broth alone. Butter and cream also contribute richness. The eight-serving estimate includes all noodles and measured fat, not just the turkey and vegetables visible on top.

Leftover turkey brings an important timing detail: making soup does not reset the age of the meat. Use properly refrigerated turkey within its safe storage window, or thaw previously frozen turkey safely. The nutrition estimate uses a generic canned-hominy proxy and cannot describe every brand’s drained kernels exactly.

  • Reheat thoroughly: bring the turkey and soup to the 165°F leftover temperature.
  • Cool promptly: divide a large batch among shallow containers rather than leaving the full pot out.
  • Label the containers: note the original turkey’s storage date as well as the soup-making date.
  • Handle noodles separately: refrigerate them promptly too; separating them is a texture choice, not permission to leave them at room temperature.

Good leftovers depend on the turkey’s earlier storage as well as how quickly the new soup is cooled.

Turkey noodle soup being ladled over egg noodles in a bowl

Bottom Line

Turkey noodle soup becomes easier to manage when the noodles are treated as their own component. The creamy broth can stay fluid, the vegetables remain visible and each bowl can be assembled to suit the person eating it. Keep the turkey’s history in mind, then enjoy a warm meal without sacrificing tomorrow’s texture.

A separate container of noodles is a small step with a useful payoff.

Turkey Noodle Soup Recipe

Laura Ambrouse
Turkey noodle soup with tender meat and broad noodles
No ratings yet
Save
Creamy turkey soup with vegetables, hominy and separately cooked egg noodles.
Estimated Recipe CostEstimated USD 29.05 per recipe / 3.63 per serving
Prep Time 25 minutes
Cook Time 1 hour
Total Time 1 hour 25 minutes
Servings: 8 servings
Course: Main Course
Cuisine: American
Calories: 653.8

Ingredients
  

Ingredients
  • 2880 ml unsalted chicken stock 240 ml for reduction, remainder for soup
  • 60 ml dry vermouth
  • 84 g unsalted butter 56 g reduction, 28 g vegetables
  • 240 ml heavy whipping cream
  • 454 g dry egg noodles
  • 150 g onion diced
  • 300 g carrots sliced
  • 200 g celery sliced
  • 9 g garlic minced
  • 560 g cooked turkey breast diced
  • 360 ml water
  • 90 g all-purpose flour
  • 220 g canned white hominy drained and rinsed
  • 140 g frozen peas
  • 15 g fresh parsley chopped
  • 3 g fine salt adjust to stock
  • 1 g ground black pepper
  • 15 ml olive oil to coat cooked noodles

Equipment

  • 1 large soup pot
  • 1 small saucepan
  • 1 Pasta pot
  • 1 Whisk

Instructions
 

Prepare and cook
  1. In a small saucepan, simmer 240 ml stock, vermouth and 56 g butter until reduced to about 80 ml. Whisk in cream and set aside; reduction does not guarantee all alcohol has evaporated.
  2. Cook egg noodles just to al dente, drain and cool briefly if preparing ahead. Toss with 15 ml olive oil; keep separate from the soup so they do not absorb all the broth.
  3. In a large pot, soften onion in the remaining 28 g butter over medium-low heat 10–15 minutes. Add carrots, celery and garlic and cook another 3–4 minutes.
  4. Add cooked turkey and the remaining 2640 ml stock. Simmer gently until vegetables are tender. Whisk flour with 360 ml cold water until smooth; stir in a ladle of hot broth, then gradually whisk the mixture into the soup.
  5. Simmer gently at least 5–10 minutes while stirring so the flour cooks and the broth thickens. Stir in the cream reduction, hominy and peas; heat the turkey and soup to 165°F (74°C).
  6. Add parsley, salt and pepper to taste. Divide noodles among bowls and ladle soup over them. Refrigerate soup and noodles separately promptly; account for the turkey’s original storage time.

Nutrition

Serving: 1portionCalories: 653.8kcalProtein: 39.8gFiber: 6g

Video

Notes

Video: Chef Billy Parisi, “The Secret Ingredients in the Perfect Turkey Noodle Soup,” originally uploaded 2023-11-24. This recipe adapts the source method; the related demonstration may use different quantities or accompaniments.
Cooked turkey standardized 560 g and drained hominy 220 g. Noodles kept separate until serving; nutrition includes all noodles, cream, butter and oil. Generic canned-hominy composition is a disclosed proxy. Turkey cost uses raw replacement weight with assumed 75% cooked yield. Vermouth energy retained conservatively. Generic Ciqual vermouth composition represents the dry vermouth and may overstate its sugar.
Nutrition is an ingredient-based estimate using ANSES Ciqual 2025 and relevant labels. Fields with incomplete ingredient data are omitted. Oil uses approximately 0.9 g/ml; wine and other thin liquids use approximate volume-to-mass conversion. Cream uses the HEB label; hominy uses USDA generic canned white hominy. Rounded small-serving label values add uncertainty.
Cost is an approximate U.S. ingredient estimate using online prices checked October 25, 2026, prorated to the stated amounts. Local prices, brands and yields vary; taxes, energy and optional sides are excluded. Garlic assumes ten usable 3 g cloves per bulb; peppers assume 150 g edible per pepper. Hominy costing uses an explicitly approximate 440 g drained yield from an imported label with the same-brand U.S. can price; this is not a verified U.S. drained weight.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it turned out!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Scroll to Top